When you’re looking for the difference between western medicine and Chinese medicine diagnosis, you should know that they both share many similarities, but are often called different things. Western medicine relies heavily on medical laboratory tests and non-invasive palpation, while Eastern medicine is based on subjective assessment of the pulse. A good medical lab test can pick up hundreds of disease markers and provide an accurate diagnosis, while a pulse form is more subjective and abstract.
Diagnostic patterns in TCM
Despite the widespread use of standardized tests for diagnosing diabetes in western medicine, there is little evidence to support their efficacy as a reliable means to diagnose the condition in TCM patients. Moreover, the two systems’ understanding of signs and symptoms may differ from one another, which could affect the reliability of the diagnostic findings. Therefore, in order to ensure high diagnostic consistency between practitioners, it is imperative to establish consensus-based methods.
In the future, the combination of both TCM and western medicine will be used to help improve the precision of diagnosis and treatment. Precision medicine is the science of customizing treatment protocols for different individuals. Diagnostic patterns in TCM and western medicine are both highly personalized, but their methods differ. For instance, the former focuses on detecting a single pattern, while the latter relies on the combinations of several patterns. Because the human body often mixes several patterns, it will be possible to study the disease by studying the mixed patterns.
Similarly, the two systems are unable to diagnose some chronic conditions. A recent study by Zhang and colleagues found that the western-style approach to RA is similar to the American College of Rheumatology’s criteria for diagnosis. However, Western diagnosis focuses on the underlying pathophysiologic disruption. Consequently, western physicians find it difficult to understand and implement the same diagnostic methods. However, this does not preclude the use of TCM therapy for chronic conditions.
However, the low diagnostic agreement between western and TCM is concerning. It may even prompt practitioners to discard TCM theory before conducting an assessment. The problem is, the TCM diagnostic format must be changed so that the standard error can be calculated with open populations. So, in the end, TCM and western medicine should work together. With proper research and clinical practice, the use of these diagnostic tools may eventually lead to a more efficient treatment for our patients.
Differential diagnosis is the foundation for treating patients. While western medicine relies on disease-based diagnosis, TCM emphasizes patient-based diagnosis. The practitioner’s observations, palpation, and smell of a patient are translated into a diagnostic syndrome. This diagnosis guides the individualised treatment for each patient. Moreover, the same disease may have different syndromes at different stages. This is because TCM considers the disease’s progression as an ever-changing process.
Different diagnosis methods differ significantly. A primary diagnostic pattern identified by a western practitioner may be incorrect in TCM, but the two systems do not always agree. Practitioners may use a different diagnostic pattern if they do not have the same experience and training. They may also differ on the importance of symptoms in TCM. This study, however, demonstrated that TCM and western diagnosis are compatible and complementary. The use of a tool such as this may improve diagnostic reliability.
Diagnostic patterns in western medicine
Diagnoses are made based on observations of disease and accompanying treatment. The development of TEAM has been influenced by socio-political factors. The author focuses on differences between TCM and MT diagnosis descriptions and explores issues surrounding their development. The results of this study may help clinicians in both Eastern and Western medicine in making better decisions about which treatment to prescribe. There are two major types of diagnostic patterns: pathophysiologic and phenomenological.
Despite these differences, the diagnostic accuracies of different datasets are similar. For example, different datasets might yield better or worse cutoff values depending on the quantity of patterns and the use of specific terms. Different datasets should be arranged in Four Examinations. Comparing different datasets may help evaluate the effectiveness of PDA in clinical practice. The current lack of international Web-based datasets for PDA studies limits the ability to perform systematic comparisons.
Although TEAM diagnoses from other systems are included in ICD-1110, there are numerous limitations of these systems. The lack of scientific knowledge of practice populations, the limited availability of data in other countries, and the lack of standardization of patterns make these approaches vulnerable. Hence, more work is needed to develop standardized definitions of patterns in TEAM systems. Besides, it is also important to conduct cross-cultural studies to assess the use of TEAM systems in different regions.
Generally, a doctor in western medicine performs a physical examination, looks at the patient’s medical history and uses X-rays to determine the cause of illness. In contrast, a Chinese physician uses inquiry and investigation to obtain diagnostic information. A practitioner may listen to the patient’s pulse in both wrists and examine the tongue, eyes, and overall color of the body. A Chinese medicine practitioner may examine the patient’s tongue and examine their overall color to determine whether any of these elements are out of balance.
When a patient presents with chest pain, nausea, fatigue, and nausea, an accurate diagnosis of angina is most likely to be given. The symptoms of disease D and its symptom S are strongly correlated and are not independent of each other. In other words, a doctor should present a diagnosis of angina based on the patient’s medical history and the presence of emphysema. These three factors are closely related and cannot be disentangled by clinician bias.
The proposed computational strategy uses a dataset containing 69 Zang-fu single patterns, grouped by Four Examinations: inquiry, auscultation-olfaction, and palpation. The Four Examinations were tested with each examination, and each combination produced concave-shaped curves with a range of average normalized accuracies. The number of examined patterns varies by the available information, with lower values yielding fewer accurate diagnoses than higher ones.
Comparisons between western medicine and TCM
A recent study explored the differences between Western and Chinese medicine. Consumers surveyed preferred traditional Chinese medicine in many scenarios, but opted for Western medicines in others. For example, Western medicines were preferred when a patient needed fast relief of symptoms, while Chinese medicine was preferable when the patient wanted to know the cause of the illness. However, these differences aren’t without their caveats. Consider the following comparisons between western medicine and TCM diagnosis:
While Western medicine emphasizes evidence-based science, Chinese medicine stresses holistic approaches and the human body as a whole system. Chinese practitioners develop inductive tools to guide the restoration of total body balance. This method focuses on the balance between Yin and Yang, as well as Qi. Traditionally, herbal medicines account for over 90% of Chinese drug sales. Both methods are effective in curing a variety of ailments, including chronic diseases.
Western scientists are concerned about the continued use of traditional therapies, particularly herbal medicines. Some TCM practitioners have discussed replacing proven Western medicines with equivalent traditional medicine. However, this debate is still raging. Some scientists, such as Richard Peto, think that the world health organization may be moving in the direction of integrating proven traditional medicine. However, the official WHO documents do not specify which remedies should be used with modern medicine. In Beijing, a representative of WHO told the Nature magazine that they do not endorse specific remedies for a particular illness.
Ultimately, comparing TCM diagnosis with western medicine is a matter of preference. Western medicine often views a peptic ulcer patient as basically healthy. This means that it is difficult to differentiate a patient from others who have the same condition. Considering that 10 percent of the male population has suffered from a peptic ulcer, all of those with the condition would be considered part of the same large group.
In a recent study, Western and Chinese medical students assessed how narrative medicine affected their knowledge and skills. Western students rated the benefits of the program positively, while students in the MS group ranked the course negatively. Comparative studies of narrative medicine in medical schools could help increase the acceptance of the course and attract more students interested in the humanities. The researchers conclude that these approaches to learning empathy and professionalism have the potential to improve medical training.
While Western medicine is more focused on the symptoms, Chinese medicine treats the entire body. Chinese medicine is designed to prevent adverse effects by addressing the underlying causes of a disease. In addition to avoiding the symptoms associated with Western medicine, Chinese medicine addresses the entire body and its overall immune system. This holistic approach prevents the recurrence of the disease by targeting the underlying cause. Although the western approach is more efficient, it has its limitations.
Leave a Reply